In sharp contrast to previous Presidential visits, the public will be shut out when Barack Obama and his family arrive on the Vineyard somewhere in a five-hour window on Sunday afternoon.
As the Martha’s Vineyard Airport and later a White House spokeswoman confirmed yesterday, there will be no chance for the media, or, more importantly, Islanders to see the First Family.
“It will be what’s called a closed arrival,” said the airport manager Sean Flynn.
“There will be no opportunity at all, really, for the public to view it. That’s the straight up, honest answer. You won’t catch a glimpse of anything.”
A presidential spokesman said later the First Family would land in Air Force One at Otis Air Base near Bourne on Cape Cod, where their arrival will be open to media, and then commute to the Island by helicopter, where it will not.
The exact time of arrival was not revealed, only that it would be some time between 9 a.m. and 2 p.m.
The Obamas’ stealthy approach bears comparison to those of the last Presidential family to regularly visit the Island, the Clintons.
For their first visit, in August of 1993, thousands of flag-waving Islanders clustered at the airport and lined the roads. Edgartown school children stood on the tarmac to greet the President and his family, and a group of children from the Boys’ and Girls’ Club held a red, white and blue banner and sang Happy Birthday to the President. White House staff planned the public details long in advance and sought the cooperation of local media in publicizing them.
President Clinton visited the Island in all but one year of his term. Each time he was accessible on arrival, and also at other events around the Island, notably at the Agricultural Fair. Numerous store owners and others around the Vineyard display photographs of the casual interactions.
While the possibility of some spontaneous interaction between the Obamas and locals cannot be ruled out, it does not look likely, going by intelligence filtering back from those few local officials who have been slightly informed of plans.
No official engagements have been scheduled; the suggestion is that the first family will sequester themselves at their rented vacation house on Blue Heron Farm. The only suggested activities off the farm were a couple of possible golf dates for the President and perhaps a private dinner or two.
The lack of wider access maintains a pattern set in Mr. Obama’s previous couple of visits to the Island, before he became President. In 2007, when candidates Obama, Hillary Clinton and John Edwards all visited in quick succession, the Clinton and Edwards campaigns held low-cost fundraisers — Mrs. Clinton’s drew several thousand people at $50 a head for the biggest ever event at the Oak Bluffs Tabernacle — while Mr. Obama held only a $2,300 per-person, private event.
If, as appears to be the plan, the Obamas lie low for the duration of their vacation, they will leave a growing media circus with no headline act. It is understood most of the major networks and cable channels plan extensive coverage. Only yesterday it was revealed the Geraldo Rivera show, on Fox, plans to broadcast from the Island on Saturday evening.
There will be media briefings for the Washington media, but otherwise the news pickings look thin, something which may play to the advantage of certain Obama critics.
Cindy Sheehan, for example, the peace activist whose son Casey was killed in the Iraq War, plans a series of media events — among them a peace vigil in Ocean Park in Oak Bluffs and an event at the Katharine Cornell Theatre in Vineyard Haven.
“In addition,” said a press release put out by her handlers, “there will be impromptu gatherings during the week.”
Right-wing activists also are reportedly targeting the President during his time on the Vineyard.
According to the Plum Line blog on the Washington Post Web site, a leaked memo from the group Conservatives for Patients’ Rights, refers to a “Martha’s Vineyard strategy.”
Says the blog “. . . this is a reference to a planned national ad targeting the public [health reform] option, that will reference the President’s vacation.”
Vineyarders themselves have a reputation for respecting the privacy of visiting celebrities and not engaging in acts of political confrontation, but some of them also are less than happy with the tight security which surrounds this visit.
Of particular concern are the restrictions which will apply to aircraft flying to and from the Island.
These are likely to completely shut down operations at Katama Airfield, and also impose stringent conditions on non-commercial flights out of the main airport.
One pilot who regularly commutes from his Edgartown home, Bill Brine, said he spent 90 minutes this week filling out forms, and expected to spend hours more clearing security while leaving and returning to the Island.
“They asked for my social security number, my pilot’s certificate number and my passport number,” he said.
“So you need a passport to leave Martha’s Vineyard. Just to be on the manifest for a private airplane leaving the Vineyard.”
He complained that the security and search procedures were the same as those required to fly in or out of the country.
“So they’re actually bringing us to the level of a foreign country,” he said.
Mike Creato, manager of the Katama Airfield and operator of Classic Avaitors biplane flights, said he was expecting to take a financial hit from the Presidential visit.
All operations other than his joy flights have been stopped. At press time he still was negotiating with the Secret Service and Federal Aviation Administration about the biplane flights.
Reader Feedback
Friday, August 21, 2009 4:08pm
This gracious and calm man and his family are on vacation. Respect the island tradition and save whatever you thought was a "brilliant" idea for some other time and place.
- Marty , Flowery Branch
Saturday, August 22, 2009 6:21am
How ridiculous to sacrifice businesses in Martha's Vineyard to accomodate a man who doesn't even belong there. Obama preaches redistribution of wealth. Appears he's distributing a good portion of that wealth to himself and his whims. For example, the junkets in Air Force One to push his atrocious policies must surely total in mega proportions by now. Egads.
- Tatty , Orlando, FL
Saturday, August 22, 2009 7:01am
Hey, Tatty.
The President's vacation isn't costing anywhere near your Bush's war in Iraq. All Presidents get Air Force One.
Save your lousy manners and stupidity for Orlando.
- Steve , Boston
Saturday, August 22, 2009 8:34am
It's funny to me how someone who is determined to comprimise qualaity health care for Americans and is set on taking our ability to make a good living and live prosperously away from most - is vacationing in a 20 million dollar beach front estate. Not only that but his disastrous effect on small business owners throughout the country will now be felt by the same that passionately voted him into office. Ask a small business owner how is line of credit is doing these days.
- Laura , Edgartown
Saturday, August 22, 2009 10:51am
Do whatever must be done to keep them safe. We can all put up with some inconvenience for a short time. The press pool ought to be situated on Nantucket! LOL! I have seen a more productive presidency in the past seven months than I had in the previous eight years.
- brendan , Yarmouth
Saturday, August 22, 2009 12:51pm
Dear Steve:
Tatty is just picking sour grapes, like the rest of that ilk. They can't bear the thought that their stupidity has been exposed.
But please, don't suggest Orlando is that way. We are polite and sometimes even intelligent; That is, when you separate us from the "touristas" like "Tatty." Those people just come from everywhere and frequently taint our original history as a laid-back, compassionate community of democrats, not unlike that of yours. (Boston is my 2d home).
I think New Englanders are not that much different from true Floridians. Even as we are smarter than "Tatty," and more polite.
I only wrote this because I cannot for the life of me, figure out why anyone would want sour grapes? Doesn't make sense.
- Robbie , Melbourne, Florida
Saturday, August 22, 2009 2:32pm
You don't need to read the hometown, to figure out most of the derogatory comments are coming from off-island. I was lucky enough to live on the Vineyard for a short while, and truly appreciate the tradition of allowing everyone to have a vacation. Lord knows, the President and his family deserve a break from the recent right-wing idiocy syndrome affecting the country worse than the swine flu!
- Craig "Red" Holland , Naples, FL
Saturday, August 22, 2009 7:00pm
Please let the president and his family vacation in peace. If all the energy in this country that is put into some of the stupid hooplaa were redirected to come up with some concrete and worthwhile ideas on healthcare, the economy, etc., we would be much better off. If you aren't happy, why don't you run for the office of president of the United States. Couldn't do much worse that the last eight years that have been such a disaster. Again, let the Obama's vacation in peace.
- John , Harrisburg, PA
Saturday, August 22, 2009 8:13pm
The first Clinton visit was Zoo City. I'd never seen so many journalists swarming around with nothing to do but dig up "local color." To judge from the clippings that friends sent me from around the country, most of them didn't know any more about Martha's Vineyard when they left than when they arrived. If they got Martha's Vineyard so wrong, when nearly everyone here speaks the same language they do, how could I possibly trust the stories they file from Sarajevo or Baghdad?
Dear Laura from Edgartown: If you really believe that it's President Obama who "is set on taking our ability to make a good living and live prosperously away from most," you could not possibly have lived here long. What has compromised our ability to make a good living -- and find year-round housing -- is the real estate insanity of the last decade. And before that started, Blue Heron Farm was not a "20 million dollar beach front estate." The beach, by the way, is on Town Cove of Tisbury Great Pond. We're not talking the Atlantic Ocean here.
- Susanna , West Tisbury
Sunday, August 23, 2009 9:18am
I am completely amazed at the biased double standard there is towards Obama. I live in Edgartown and don't support the President yet everywhere I go I am bombardes w/'Bo bama' signs, 'Summer Whitehouse' signs. . . etc. etc. How can any one with any sense or intelligence think that the way out of this economic disaster is to bailout all of the big banks, yet keep the lending closed to small businesses? Go to canada or Europe and see for yourself that socialized medicine is a failure. Who with any sense of intelligence would seek to adopt failed policies? Everytime you read the paper here it is completely biased. It is as if everyone believes that Obama and is family are the second coming of Christ. I have never seen a human being so adorned. You people need to wake up and smell the coffee. But of course that is hard since the only news you can read around here is about Michele Obama's sleeveless dresses and her plans for the summer time activities for her children. Does anyone remember the wrath that President Bush received when he was in Texas for vacation?? What a flippin joke!!
- Laura , Edgartown, Mass
Sunday, August 23, 2009 4:20pm
hey laura
you want obama to rent a $2500 a week cape style house down in katama? would that make you feel better?
i've a small business owner all my life and if the the current bill proposed(or 1 of them) is enacted, it could save me 500K a year. Thought I'm sure you were as vocal about that as Bush tax cut for the top 1% and trillion $$ war budget, right?
- john , Edagrtown
Sunday, August 23, 2009 4:52pm
Relax, everyone. O's approval rating is dropping every day - he is self-imploding, with or without the name-calling. This is the reality of the situation.
- wetoldyouso , Edg
Sunday, August 23, 2009 7:41pm
Isn't it ironic that a man who campaigned on openness and transparency is shrouded in secrecy by not letting us serfs enter the airport? Back when Clinton was here it was a fun time, party atmosphere. The president works for all of us - funny he's choosing to act more like a King. I hope he gets the memo that we don't like the exclusion tactics.
- Joey , Oak Bluffs
Sunday, August 23, 2009 9:18pm
count your lucky stars that this visit by the obamas and all the folks that come w/them, brings valuable attention to one of our country's most wonderful coastal, historic, proud, multicultral, still a little wild gems. i love every memory i am lucky to have of the island. maybe through respectful attention to the many acres of protected areas and conservancy programs, and to artful, simple living in sync w/the sea and to tourism but reverence to privacy... maybe i the attention will be great all around. let us love the island with those of you who are so lucky to live there year-round.
- p.susan sharrock , historic german village
Sunday, August 23, 2009 9:34pm
Hey John from Edgartown - Be specific! Tell me which one of Obama's riduclous policies are going to save you $500K?? I work with business owners all over the north east and NONE of them share your sentiment. He's unprepared for the job and guess what the reason is: HE'S NEVER HELD A JOB IN THE PRIVATE SECTOR. This administration is going to be the death of us. You know the saying the devil you know is better than the devil you don't know. OBAMA is the Devil you don't know. Trust me on this one. He's spiraling us into failure but hey as long as he can vacation on a $20million dollar plus estate and take his girls to London, Russia and Paris this summer I can see that he understands how the rest of America feels. Seriously you brain washed Vineyarders need to get a clue!!!
- Laura , Edgartown
Sunday, August 23, 2009 11:17pm
Paris, the Grand Canyon, Martha's Vineyard...Jeez, this is the Obama's third vacation in the past few weeks... This is getting a bit absurd! Shouldn't he be focused on working on the current, multiple crisis going on instead of sightseeing with the kids?
- KFab , NYC, NY
Sunday, August 23, 2009 11:49pm
Mr Obama, if you saw my truck along the route covered with a bunch of *Tea Bags* please dont think I am part of a mob or I'm a Brown Shirt or that I am Anti-American. But I always remember the words Hillary Clinton was "screaming" when she spoke at the Democratic Party's main fundraising event of the year, the Jefferson Jackson Bailey Dinner.
"I am sick and tired of people who call you unpatriotic if you debate this (Bush) administration's policies, Clinton shouted. "We are Americans and have the right to participate and debate "ANY" administration!"
I figure that I could not disagree with you more on Every Single Isssue so far and this is my only way to participate in a country which I served so Honorably in the military back in the day.
- James , Edgartown
Monday, August 24, 2009 12:38pm
let's hope they have the same hi-tide they had in Maine
- Gus , Portland
Monday, August 24, 2009 12:46pm
Hey John in Boston: your Obama has outspent Bush's eight years (including war funding) in six months. . .and that's prior to his health care atrocity. Tsk tsk tsk.
- Andrew , Seattle
Monday, August 24, 2009 3:41pm
Seems to me, if the airfield gets
Federal money, it's a public place
and the folks have a right to go
there if they wish, no matter whom
is traveling there.
- James in Darkest Arkansas , Fort Smith
Monday, August 24, 2009 3:43pm
Looking at these comments, It becomes apparent that Vineyard is full of self righteous narrow minded liberals. Liberals, who espouse open mindedness, and a free exchange of ideas don't seem to want to freely exchange anything except contempt for people who think differently than themselves. How boring.
- Mediamirror , Fly-Over Territory
Monday, August 24, 2009 4:14pm
Obama has his transperancy, America can see right through him for what he really is, a duplicitous wannabe dictator.
- rmf , sacramento
Monday, August 24, 2009 5:02pm
Please, keep The Obamanation and his family there.....that way he can just destroy your paradise instead of the entire country. This is the most incompetent, hubris,inept idiot ever elected to POTUS.....hope you have power for his 37 teleprompters!
- Phoebe , NYC
Monday, August 24, 2009 6:01pm
A president doesn't have privacy in public places. If he wants privacy then go to Camp David. This man is such an egomaniac. He's destroying this country faster than anyone could have ever predicted.
- Jj , Orange
Monday, August 24, 2009 7:06pm
The total hypocrisy of the left never fails to astound me. "Let the president have his private vacation"
When President Bush took his vacation on his ranch, his entire staff went with him so he could work a few hours everyday but that was absolutely unacceptable to the press and the left. He wasn't suppose to take any vacation. HYPOCRITES!!!!
- Dedee , Park Rapids, MN
Monday, August 24, 2009 7:22pm
The rules for private aircraft need to be revised. In the Chicago area, when the President is at O'Hare airport, all of the local private airports are shut down. The closest airport you can fly your private plane out of is DeKalb. They do that for every President, it's just that Obama has been traveling a lot more than Bush or Clinton.
This isn't just private pilots; I was delayed on a commercial flight from Seattle to Chicago because Obama was in Las Vegas! Years ago Clinton stopped traffic at LAX when he got a haircut on Air Force One while it was on the ground. He changed his traveling patterns after that, paying more attention to how people were inconvenienced by him.
This is something Obama needs to do- pay more attention to inconveniencing others, because the Sevret Service, the FAA, and the rest of the bureaucrats sure aren't going to pay attention to citizens who are inconvenienced.
Although I have to admit, I'm a little frightened to be writing this (only a little.) With Obama's Chicago staff tracking emails from people, I wonder if I'll get a visit from the Secret Service for writing this?
- Philster , Chicago
Monday, August 24, 2009 7:44pm
Mediamirror wrote: "Looking at these comments, It becomes apparent that Vineyard is full of self righteous narrow minded liberals. Liberals, who espouse open mindedness, and a free exchange of ideas don't seem to want to freely exchange anything except contempt for people who think differently than themselves. How boring."
What comments have you been reading? Most of the ones here aren't from the Vineyard at all, and of those that are from the Vineyard, at least half are anti-Obama. FYI, the towns of Martha's Vineyard are Tisbury (aka Vineyard Haven), Oak Bluffs, Edgartown, West Tisbury, Chilmark, and Aquinnah (still often called Gay Head).
- Susanna , West Tisbury
Monday, August 24, 2009 7:46pm
To all you ‘political-pundits’, left or right, you might want to wake up and get real, you have one ‘snake (Government) with two heads’ and that does not just apply to the United States of America. We are all in the same leaky boat and if we don’t unite, we will all go down.
- peace , Sydney
Monday, August 24, 2009 8:06pm
Wow, I cannot believe that people can be so fired up towards our president to take the time to neglect their personal responsibilities and attack him with largely non literal complaints and vices. to condemn one of the best opportunities for morality that has been elected into office in our generation. I think this is where it is applicable to repeat him, and say Go back to school, or lets see your business plan. It's not the fault of the administration to cut back on lending, it's the failure for sound idealogy and inadequecies in worldview & dynamic thinking that render our country impeding in Health care, small business reform and tax rehabilitaiton for the wealthy. Save your anger for your business plans, and redeem our President for having your best interest at heart.
thank you Susan Sharock, for being aware enough to turn the tide, that war and indeed hatred to not suffice to gain much of anything other than more war and hatred. I love Oak Bluffs, and it's a sign of respect and affiliation that my president would love my island also.
- Daniele , Oak Bluffs
Monday, August 24, 2009 8:09pm
HOW DARE THIS PRESIDENT SET ABOUT TO PLAY GOLF WHEN HE SENDS YOUNG AMERICAN GIS TO THEIR DEATH EVERY DAY IN AFGHANISTAN!
- Mick B. , City of Angels
Monday, August 24, 2009 8:19pm
I don't mind the President taking vacation at Martha's and though I disagree with his direction, the job has to be incredibly tough. Let the man spend some quiet time with his family. As for the media, I think a better spot for them would be a mile or so off the island, preferably a couple of leagues beneath the waves.
- Ruben , La Quinta, CA
Monday, August 24, 2009 8:35pm
"nero fiddled while rome burned" for eight years we heard that ,,,, it seems that BDR (bush derangement syndrome) has evolved. people want to start talking about the cost of a war. but dissmiss the fact that its still going on and,, the fact that in 6 months our current president and the house and senate have spent exponentualy more than the entire combined military action for 8 years prior. {sarcasm}i'm so shocked that ciny shehhan isn't picketing in front of the $20 million estate
- philgorp , Alva Fl
Monday, August 24, 2009 8:48pm
Why is anyone surprised at all the fawning over Obama? Remember, these are the same people who kept electing Ted Kennedy, even after he drove his wife to drink and Mary Jo into the drink...and left her there to die until his blood alcohol level rose back to legal limits. It's not like these self-deluded "brainiacs" have any critical thinking skills.
Other than the intolerant liberal fascists, Marxist Vineyard is a lovely island.
- Mille , Orlando
Monday, August 24, 2009 9:03pm
Obama is an arrogant and narcissistic micro manager. One day, hopefully most of the people who voted for him will realize that.
- Scott , Columbia
Monday, August 24, 2009 10:07pm
Stay up there.
- grunk , linthicum MD
Monday, August 24, 2009 10:20pm
It would be nice if Mr Obama would take a nice long vacation for the next 3 years
- Gonzo
Tuesday, August 25, 2009 12:12am
If Obama and the other political hacks in DC are so concerned about our health care, why not give us the same deal they voted for themselves? Both sides of the aisle have taken care of themselves on the backs of the poor tax payer. The O has got to go!
- Patty , Irvine
Tuesday, August 25, 2009 12:49am
Obama doesn't have a problem trotting out his family when it is politically expedient and he is trying to portray himself as caring dad. He didn't say a word when Sarah Palin's kids were being maligned and abused by the press.
- Carole , Canby, OR
Tuesday, August 25, 2009 8:06am
Isn't there anyone out there willing to have an intelligent fact based discussion, presenting all the facets' pro's and con's on health care coverage and all the other critical issues? Does anyone do their homework?
I love the Vineyard, but am stunned by all the name calling, personal attacks and jingoisms.What an enormous waste of time. Time we cannot afford to lose.
Sober up America. Try to recall some of the intelligence and dignity you may have learned in school.
If you have a solution to a problem, share it. Otherwise, let others do their job as best they can.
- roger barkin , ripton,vt
Tuesday, August 25, 2009 8:36am
If he is on vacation can we put his spending on vacation?
- N1P , GR, MI